Non-surgical endodontic retreatment – a second chance to save a tooth
Featured Products Promotional FeaturesPosted by: Dental Design 5th November 2020
For patients receiving a recommendation of root canal therapy, the risk of failure must be understood and accepted. As with any dental procedure, there is no guarantee of success, although success rates when it is performed by an endodontic specialist are high. Root canal therapy, more than any other type of treatment, comes with a mythology all of its own; that it’s painful, invasive, will leave you wiped out and unable to speak or eat properly for days.
But when patients are doing their research before going ahead (and we can assume that most modern patients will be), they will find a great deal of myth-busting, positive material about this procedure – root canal therapy is nothing to be scared of. The word “therapy” itself means to heal or relieve – endodontic treatment does not deserve the bad press it has received in the past. The aim of endodontic treatment isn’t to cause pain, but to get a patient free from oral pain, to save their tooth and, ultimately, restore them to good health and wellbeing.
An endodontically treated tooth, always the preferred option
But things can and do go wrong. If a patient is coming to you for primary endodontic therapy, the possible reasons for failure and rationales for retreatment being necessary must be discussed as part of your planning and initial discussions. The fact that endodontic retreatment even exists should not be perceived as a negative; it represents a second chance to save a tooth, rather than extract it. For most of your patients, retaining more of their natural teeth for as long as possible is always going to be their preferred option; an endodontically treated tooth is just better.
The reasons for non-surgical endodontic retreatment are wide-ranging and not all of them are within the control of patient or practitioner. Every root canal system is unique, and the specific anatomy plays “a significant role” in endodontic treatment success or failure.[i] Non-surgical endodontic retreatment may be required because of a brand-new problem, such as new decay which led to another infection. This may not have been present when the patient initially presented for their primary root canal therapy. Other situations that may result in non-surgical endodontic retreatment include a new injury or fracture, a broken crown, or an existing restoration that now has to be redesigned.
A complex treatment
Yet failure may also be due to poor treatment the first time around. Healing may have been compromised because the crown or restoration was not placed soon enough, narrow canals may not have been detected or obturation may have been incomplete; these are just some of the reasons for treatment failure. Endodontic failure is a complex and delicate issue – literally, as well as medically. In a 10-year period up to 2020, there were over 1,000 claims to the DDU involving root canal treatment as the “primary element”.[ii] Endodontic therapy should, of course, only be performed by a specialist using the highest-quality tools and materials, but patient dissatisfaction can also result from poor communication and a failure of the practitioner(s) and/or practice(s) involved to properly manage expectations. This is a cycle; a well-prepared patient will want to work with you, and will know that your partnership, as well as their own behaviours, are a crucial part of their expectations being met and their treatment being a success.
Just like primary root canal therapy, non-surgical endodontic retreatment must only be performed by a specialist and there are additional complicating factors too. These include the need to completely remove all filling materials from previous treatment. A specialist performing an endodontic retreatment must also “address deficiencies or repair defects that are pathologic or iatrogenic in origin… (and) confirm mechanical failures, previously missed canals or radicular sub-crestal fractures”.[iii]
During the retreatment, the specialist will reshape, clean and refill for a result that will hopefully remain stable with the natural tooth preserved for years to come. Precise techniques are required, along with the highest quality tools and materials, so you can work quickly and efficiently and deliver a minimally invasive, comfortable procedure. Once the pulp chamber has been re-accessed, existing gutta-percha must be removed before proceeding to reshaping. New from COLTENE is the REMOVER file, to mechanically remove all obturation material, without the need for a solvent, which many patients find toxic. With no solvent required, and just one file, you can quickly move on to re-shaping – just select instruments from COLTENE’s HyFlex™ EDM file sequence for the best results.
Non-surgical endodontic retreatment is sometimes necessary, for a variety of reasons, yet it can be a highly positive experience for the patient, who might feel frustrated at their initial treatment’s failure. Endodontic retreatment, delivered by a specialist, using advanced techniques and high-quality tools, is upgraded endodontic treatment, with every chance of long-term success.
For more on COLTENE, visit www.coltene.com,
email info.uk@coltene.com or call 0800 254 5115.
[i] Ruddle CJ. Nonsurgical endodontic retreatment. CDA Journal. 2004 Jun: 1-4.
[ii] Risk management in root canal treatment. The DDU, 1 May 2020. Link: https://www.theddu.com/guidance-and-advice/guides/risk-management-in-root-canal-treatment (accessed July 2020).
[iii] CDA Journal. 2004 Jun: 1-4.








