Is it time to change direction in the contract reform programme? – Barry Cockcroft
NewsPosted by: Dental Design 12th October 2018
Using existing flexibilities could improve things quicker for everybody, says BARRY COCKCROFT…
I would be surprised if any of the people involved in the contract reform programme at its initiation nearly 10 years ago would be satisfied with the extent of progress to date.
The transformation from a system based on dentists controlling access to dentistry, as they had since 1948, to a NHS commissioned system in 2006, was a much more significant change involving amending primary legislation and, despite being fiercely opposed by the British Dental Association, was still completed in much less time. The big difference was that access to dentistry was then a big political issue; vast areas of the country had no access to NHS dental services and it had been declining since the swingeing cut in item of service fees in 1992. The government of the day was committed to the concept and made resources available to deliver the change. The process effectively started with the production of the Options for Change report, which was commissioned in response to long-standing complaints from the BDA about the item of service treadmill and was published in 2002. The report recommended the introduction of local commissioning of primary care dental services, and the whole process was completed by April 2006, a four-year period.
Since the contract reform process started there has been little change in the basic principles; the original clinical pathways remain largely unaltered, they were, after all, based on best clinical practice and evidence-based prevention is delivered as it should be (but this is already required under the existing contract and there is a box on the paperwork to say DBOH guidelines have been complied with).
But the business model is proving difficult as proper implementation of NICE guidelines on patient recalls means that healthy patients attend less frequently and the number of individual courses of treatment reduces with an impact on patient charge revenue and UDA delivery.
The issue of UDA delivery and how it is seen as part of the contract and a lack of understanding of the legislation (whether deliberate or not) is at the heart of the problem. I remember in the early days of the first reform process, when we were consulting with the profession, the Chair of the GDPC at the time wrote an opinion piece in the British Dental Journal (BDJ) saying that this was “a rigid target-based system and should be rejected out of hand”; this was factually incorrect but ticked the political box at the time. A few years later Susie Sanderson, then Chair of the BDA Executive Board, writing in the same opinion slot in the BDJ, said, quite rightly, that the problem was not that the system was rigid but the flexibilities that were present in the legislation were not being used enough. As was often the case, Susie was correct.
Unfortunately the commissioners often found it easier to manage contracts in a rigid way and usually did not have the knowledge and support from their professional advisers to use this flexibility to everybody’s advantage.
The legislation does allow the NHS to commission and remunerate providers outside of UDAs. As oral health improves the ability to meet contractually agreed levels of delivery purely by delivering UDAs is going to get ever more difficult, but other areas of need which are impossible to properly remunerate using the same UDA regime, which is used in routine dental practice, are crying out for investment.
The older dentate population, some of whom are residents in care homes (but the majority are still in their own homes), are often desperately in need of care. The NHS is often paying way over the odds in the form of secondary care tariffs for oral surgery, which could be delivered in primary care, providing a more convenient service for patients and saving the NHS significant revenue. This should happen, maintaining the viability of general dental practices and developing a more diverse career structure for practitioners. It would also be possible to fund local preventive initiatives focused on reducing inequalities, such as the Teeth Team and Start Well initiatives.
One can learn a lot from history and one of the (few) benefits of getting older is that you have a memory of times gone by. Dentists do not like the current system – they believe it is target-based, all commissioned systems are, and they are not in control. But the fact that dentists were instrumental in creating access problems when they had control led to the 2006 reforms. Before 2006 dentists were paid on an item of service basis, usually referred to as “the treadmill”, and the target was based on what they wanted to earn from the NHS and how much time commitment they wished to make. If a dentist, or group of dentists, decided to reduce their NHS commitment the NHS was powerless to replace those services – this was the fundamental change delivered by the introduction of local commissioning.
Overall the contract has little impact on outcomes; the vast majority of dentists just get on doing the correct thing for their patients and we can see this in oral health and access data.
I often see the phrase “a failed contract” used, but how has it failed? The overall percentage of 5-year-old children with caries experience has fallen from 30.9 per cent in 2008 to 23.3 per cent in 2017, probably the most rapid rate of improvement since the introduction of fluoride toothpaste in the late 1960s. Latest data show that there were 5.5 million fluoride varnish applications last year, compared with none in general dental practice prior to 2007. Overall access has risen from around 30 million regular attendees in 2006 to around 36 million now if you include access to both NHS and private care. The advantage of a commissioned system is that an increase in private provision is not directly linked to a fall in NHS services as it was pre-2006.
The NHS now has the ability to tackle access-related problems, but it just needs to make the investment, before 2006 it did not have the tools.
Dentists are unhappy with the payment system, but then they always have been and always will be! The prototype contract model that I see as the best option contains elements of capitation and UDAs for complex treatment; I can see now that the complaint, if this were ever to be rolled out, would be that one target has been replaced by two!
The real problem with the contract reform programme now is that instead of getting on and working together with the NHS on using the existing flexibilities, and in Local Professional Networks we have the perfect bodies to lead this locally, the system seems to be almost totally static waiting for the outcome of contract reform.
Repeated learning from the programme has suggested that it takes at least three years to derive any meaningful learning from piloting, so the recent announcement of more pilots suggests that there will be no substantial progress until at least after the next election – and then what?
The contract reform process was initiated after the critical Health Select Committee report in 2008, which said there had been no improvement in access or evidence of a more preventive approach. Data on access is measured retrospectively and DBOH was not published until late 2007 so, in my view, the report was premature. We now have evidence of improved access, evidence of more preventive activity and improved oral health, so why not ask the Select Committee to look again?








