Self-employed associates, CEST and changes ahead…
Featured Products Promotional FeaturesPosted by: Dental Design 4th June 2020
The self-employed status of associate dentists has been a topic of discussion for a while. In HMRC’s Employment Status Manual, updated in 2019, it states that when dental practices use the standard, approved terms of agreement for associates, “the income of the associate dentist is assessable under trading income rules and not as employment income.”[i]
Recent articles that can be retrieved regarding self-employment and associate dentists show a strong, common theme, namely that the writing could be on the wall! In 2018, HMRC wrote to around 50 dentists, asking for clarity on their self-employed status, in a move which many saw as a challenge. Does HMRC want to (ahem) encourage associates onto the payroll? That’s a matter of debate, but chatter has increased on how financially disastrous it would be for practices, if HMRC decided that they had to treat their associates as employed.
There are also legal implications in failing to properly define a person’s status.[ii] As a dental practice owner, you’ll know that associate dentists do enjoy tax benefits by being self-employed. But are you confused – and worried – that you might be risking a fine by engaging their services?
To complicate matters further, at time of writing, changes to IR35 (off-payroll working rules) are due to come in after 6 April. Briefly, the changes mean a roll-out of the rules that applied to contractors in the public sector, to medium and large-sized private companies. It also means that the responsibility for determining if an engagement is classed as employed or self-employed for tax purposes, will be the responsibility of the contractor. Are you thinking this could be a headache in terms of time, money and hassle? Fear not, the good news is that HMRC has an online tool, called CEST (Check Employment Status for Tax), that you can use to establish employment status. HMRC wants all dental practices to use CEST when it engages the services of an associate dentist.
Sadly, the not-so-good news is that since it was introduced in 2017, CEST has hardly established a rabid fanbase. The main criticism is that in borderline cases, it has not provided a definitive answer. At the end of 2019, the tool was improved by adding more questions and updating others, in order that detailed information can now be considered and errors can be either reduced or eliminated. HMRC insists that it will stand by any result from CEST, and if the information inputted is not only correct but in accordance with its guidance, that the result will be accurate. However, critics continue to maintain that CEST still does not account for certain key factors, crucially “for mutuality of obligation between contractors and their clients,” according to the Association of Independent Professionals and the Self-Employed (IPSE).
This is a complex, multi-layered issue. Although not all of the threads involved are solely financial, speak with a specialist dental accountant, such as the experts at Lansdell & Rose about this, and if you need to consider how your practice is structured, in terms of who does the work and when.
The entire practice will benefit when you establish tax-efficient and HMRC compliant structures for both employees and self-employed contractors. Don’t get caught out – seeking clarity around the issue of self-employed associates will give you peace of mind and allow you to get on with the job of providing quality dentistry.
For more information please visit http://lansdellrose.co.uk or call Lansdell & Rose on 020 7376 9333.
[i] HMRC Employment Status Manual. Last updated 29 November 2019. Link: https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/employment-status-manual/esm4030 (December 2019)
[ii] Dental associates; workers or self-employed? The tide is turning. 14 June 2017. Link: http://jfhlaw.co.uk/dental-associates-workers-self-employed-tide-turning/ (accessed December 2019)








