Patient compliance depends on tolerance of the orthodontic appliance used
Featured Products Promotional FeaturesPosted by: Dental Design 11th November 2020
Fixed orthodontics is a gold standard treatment in many cases, but the appliances are not always well tolerated by patients. Dr Chris Rutter presents a case where an alternative treatment was needed for a patient concerned about the appearance of her anterior teeth.
A patient presented with concerns about the appearance of her upper and lower anterior teeth. She had previously tried fixed orthodontics, but struggled to tolerate the appliance and had it removed after only 1 week of treatment. She was now interested in a removable appliance as a possible alternative.
Initial photographs were taken and the patient returned a week later for further assessment. At this point, impressions were taken along with an OPG scan. A comprehensive orthodontic assessment was conducted, including centric relation evaluation and a full medical and social history (Table 1). The patient had Ehlers-Danlos syndrome and exhibited hypermobility in the jaw. She was a non-smoker and drank alcohol socially.
Table 1
| Skeletal Pattern | Class I | |
| FMPA | Average | |
| Lower Face Height | Average | |
| Facial Asymmetry | Normal | |
| Displacement on closure | None | |
| Nasial-labial angle | Normal | |
| TMJ | NAD | |
| Soft Tissues | Competent lips and average lip line. Pink, firm and stippled gingiva with some BOP | |
| Overjet | Decreased | |
| Overbite | Normal | |
| Crossbite | Canine crossbite LR3 with UR2 | |
| Displacement on closure | None | |
| Incisor relationship | Class I | |
| Molar relationship | Right: Class I / Left: Class 1 | |
| Canine relationship | Right: Class II ½ nit / left: Class I | |
| Teeth Present | 7654321 | 1234567 |
| 7654321 | 123457 | |
| Centrelines | Upper aligned relative to facial midline
Lower displaced 2mm to the right |
|
Caries were detected mesially in UR6 and distally in UR5, which were confined to the enamel. This was discussed with the patient in order to halt caries progression and restoration for the effected teeth was offered. Otherwise, the patient had minimally restored dentition, good oral hygiene and good periodontal health. Some calculus was recorded in the upper left and lower right quadrants.
Treatment plan
The patient would visit the dental hygienist to bring her periodontal condition under control prior to commencing orthodontic treatment. For anterior alignment, the appliances offered included upper and lower Inman Aligners, upper and lower ClearSmile Aligners or upper aligners only. The opportunity for composite edge bonding and tooth whitening were offered post alignment, as per the ABB (Align, Bleach and Bond) concept.
The patient chose to begin with alignment of the upper arch only, using clear aligners. Photos and a VPS impression were sent to the IAS Laboratory for an Archwize™ simulation, confirming suitability of the case for treatment. This suggested the ClearSmile Aligners as a preferable solution, as the required 0.7mm of space creation was well within the appliance’s limitations. A radiograph was also taken to assess the interproximal caries and root morphology pre-orthodontics. This confirmed 5% interproximal bone loss and caries location.
The treatment process was discussed with the patient, explaining all benefits and limitations, as well as the expected ideal and compromised treatment outcomes (Table 2). Information was also provided for the patient to take home and read, before fully informed consent was obtained to proceed.
Table 2:
| Problem List |
| Gingivitis
Calculus Caries UR5 and UR6 Upper arch crowding Lower arch crowding Crossbite LR3 Non coincident centrelines Incisal wear
|
| Ideal Treatment – Aims: |
| Stabilise gingival condition and caries
Align upper and lower arches with comprehensive orthodontics Correct crossbite Restore incisal wear
|
| Compromised Treatment – Aims: |
| Stabilise gingival condition and caries
Align upper anterior teeth Compromise lower canine position and adjust occlusion accordingly Correct crossbite as much as possible Restore incisal wear
|
Treatment provision
During the initial fit appointment, the patient was given instructions on how to place and remove the aligners safely, as well as oral hygiene advice. The importance of patient compliance was highlighted in order to achieve the very best results.
Interproximal reduction (IPR) was performed throughout treatment, following the suggestions made by the Archwize™ lab analysis. A series of three ClearSmile Aligners commenced, with the patient returning to the practice approximately every 2 weeks for review.
In the end, two sets of refining aligners were fabricated to encourage the final movement of the anterior teeth – further labial movement was required to correct the crossbite. Once both I and the patient were happy with the position of the teeth, impressions were taken for whitening trays and retainers. Philips Zoom Nightwhite 16% CP was used to whiten the teeth at home and composite bonding was placed using the reverse triangle technique to optimise smile aesthetics. Both a fixed retainer and Essix retainer were then provided for long-term retention. An Essix retainer was also provided for the lower arch, designed to prevent any problems from any parafunction the patient may experience.
Case appraisal
Overall, this case went well. A satisfactory outcome was achieved using a method of treatment that the patient tolerated much better than the original fixed orthodontics she tried. In hindsight, I could have emphasised the benefits of treating both arches at the outset, although this would have ultimately still been the patient’s decision.
Case images

Figure 1 – Pre treatment smile

Figure 2 – Pre treatment right view

Figure 3 – Pre treatment left view

Figure 4 – Pre treatment retracted closed bite

Figure 5 – Pre treatment retracted open bite

Figure 6 – Pre treatment right lateral

Figure 7 – Pre treatment left lateral

Figure 8 – Pre treatment upper occlusal view

Figure 9 – Pre treatment lower occlusal view

Figure 10 – Pre treatment chin up view

Figure 11 – Pre treatment upper arch isolated

Figure 12 – Post treatment smile

Figure 13 – Post treatment anterior retracted

Figure 14 – Post treatment right lateral

Figure 15 – Post treatment upper occlusal view
For more information on upcoming IAS Academy training courses, including those for the Inman Aligner and Aligner system, please visit www.iasortho.com or call 01932 336470 (Press 1)
Author bio:
Chris graduated from the University of Birmingham in 2008 and worked in the NHS for several years before transitioning to private dentistry. The main scope of Chris’ practice today is providing smile design along with tooth alignment and minimally invasive dentistry.
As private dentistry is constantly evolving, Chris spends a large amount of time attending practical and theoretical courses. He aims to offer the best possible treatments to his patients, from routine dentistry such as white fillings or teeth whitening to more complex restorative work such as veneers and facial aesthetics.
https://www.instagram.com/chris.dentist/








